agency team hero image

Meet Your City & Shire Agency Brightway Insurance Team

The key to exceptional insurance coverage starts with an agent who truly understands your needs. Our City & Shire Agency team lives right here in the community. We know the unique risks, assets, and lifestyles of Millerton residents.

Let's talk.

1 John St
Suite 302
Millerton, NY 12546

Talk to an agent

518-246-5830

Manage Existing Policies

myBrightway

About John

John has been an insurance professional since 2001. He opened his eponymous full-service John Wiltshire Agency, after working as a producer and client relations executive for the largest family-owned insurance brokerage in America. In 2019, the John Wiltshire Agency joined forces with City & Shire Agency Inc. and is now fully incorporated in C&S. Apart from his obvious experience in the insurance business, John brings with him an empathetic and insightful point of view.

About Alicia

Alicia has worked alongside John from the beginning as a customer service representative. She later became a licensed agent in Massachusetts, New York and Connecticut, opening City & Shire Insurance Agency in May of 2019. As President of the company, Alicia handles the day-to-day operations, standard lines, marketing and customer service.

Visit us to learn more about Millerton Insurance

We're eager to help you find the right insurance online or in-person. Visit our office to meet your new insurance team.

Our Office

1 John St
Suite 302
Millerton, NY 12546

Office Hours

Monday-Friday: 8:30 a.m. to 5 p.m.
Saturday-Sunday: By Appointment Only

Let's go!

Ready for the brighter way?

Get a quote on policies customized just for you.

agency home hero image
The City & Shire Agency

©2026 Brightway Insurance

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.