agency team hero image

Meet Your Casey Agency Brightway Insurance Team

The key to exceptional insurance coverage starts with an agent who truly understands your needs. Our Casey Agency team lives right here in the community. We know the unique risks, assets, and lifestyles of St. Augustine & Anastasia Island residents.

Let's talk.

108 Sea Grove Main Street, Suite B
St. Augustine, FL 32080

Talk to an agent

904-217-7547

About Ashley

A Florida native, Ashley has lived in St. Augustine for over 27 years. He began his career as a Catastrophe Claim Adjuster with the nation’s largest Homeowners insurance carrier which has given him valuable experience that he puts to work helping customers ensure they are properly protected. 

Ashley serves his community as a Rotarian and member of the Chamber of Commerce.  He is a graduate of Leadership St. Johns and the University of North Florida, and works with the United Way of St. Johns County.

About Lisa

Lisa Messler joined Brightway, The Ashley Casey Agency, in 2018. A resident of St. Augustine, she is dedicated to helping clients understand what they are insuring and adjusting coverage to fit her clients’ needs.

In her free time, Lisa enjoys spending time with her family and building memories.

About Raymond

Raymond Gregory has been in the insurance industry for over 18 years and with Brightway for 15. Listening to customers and providing the best options protecting their assets is Raymond’s greatest strength. Outside of the office, Raymond enjoys golfing, fishing and snow skiing with his family.

About Julie

Julie Settle joined Brightway, The Ashley Casey Agency, in 2023. A resident of St. Augustine, she is dedicated to helping clients get the right coverage that protects what they care about most. Before joining Brightway, Julie was a Mortgage Lender.

In her free time, Julie enjoys taking weekend trips and playing with her husky.

About Lori

Lori Stamper joined Brightway, The Ashley Casey Agency, in 2023 with over 20 years of experience in the insurance industry. A resident of Green Cove Springs, she is dedicated to helping clients get the right coverage that protects what they care about most in the ever-changing Florida insurance market. In her free time, Lori enjoys spending time with her husband and family in the great outdoors.

Visit us to learn more about St. Augustine & Anastasia Island Insurance

We're eager to help you find the right insurance online or in-person. Visit our office to meet your new insurance team.

Our Office

108 Sea Grove Main Street, Suite B
St. Augustine, FL 32080

Office Hours

Monday-Friday: 9 a.m. to 5:30 p.m.
Saturday: By Appointment Only
Sunday: Closed

Let's go!

Ready for the brighter way?

Get a quote on policies customized just for you.

agency home hero image
alt
The Casey Agency
Brightway Service Department

©2024 Brightway Insurance

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.